Theoretically, there should be a great deal of potential in Facebook advertising. The idea, of course, is that ads are highly targeted based on the information in your user profile: the more info you add about the kinds of things they like, the better idea Facebook has about what they are actually interested in, and can serve ads accordingly.
Unfortunately, it doesn’t work that way in real life. While I see a lot of ads for things that I like, I am also left scratching my head on other ads, wondering “why on earth did they serve that ad to me?”
So what it boils down to is just how good at targeting is Facebook? Robert Brady at Righteous Marketing talked about the same problem in a recent blog post:

Two ads from the same site at the same time. Give me a break.
“I’m a 28 year-old guy who is single. I’ve set my relationship status to single. Therefore, I see ads for dating sites, dating sites, and more dating sites. Based on my ads there must be at least a bazillion different dating sites that feel I am exactly who they want on their site.The only problem: I don’t use dating sites. So I give Facebook my feedback and hope for some different ads. Something I might be interested in.
Every time I see that little message and have a little hope that my ads will improve. Do they? No. Facebook may get a lot of heat for their privacy settings and policies, but I would really like a little honesty. If you tell me that my feedback will improve the ads, please improve my ads.”
From the advertisers point of view, the situation appears to be equally dismal. A longtime friend and client recently took part in a national test (on her vendor’s dime), and reported that she didn’t see any trackable sales inquiries during the weeklong test. She even used CallCap and a special landing page to track inbound inquiries.
Moreover, she and her brother both set their profile interests in such a way as to see the ads their vendor was actually running on their behalf. They were nowhere in sight.So what’s your experience? Inquiring minds want to know.
Tags: facebook ads, PPC, social media marketing
No Comments